darthtang
i am pretty sure it is a demotion for Gen. Petraus, b/c he was McCrystals boss. i am not sure exactly what that means but he is probably the best choice to get afghanistan back on track. hopefully he will be able to meet the goals/timelines put in place.
scottnlisa- i am not going to even get started. im finishing up my THIRD tour as an infantryman in iraq. the changes from 2003, 2006, and 2009 are so immense its hard to imagine its the same country. the WMD thing, we (the united states) have all the documents of the anthrax/sarin gas etc that we sold saddam in the 80s, plus all the pics of the kurds being gassed. sorry we didnt find a huge factory of the stuff or US troops didnt get gassed in the invasion. but the crap was here just not in huge quantities. i could go on an on, but the fact is Gen Petraus did turn the war in the right direction and we will be able to leave iraq with our heads held high knowing that its up to the iraqis to do with their country as they please.