It may survive (the panther grouper) but would you want to be forced to live in a home where you had to constantly breathe in thick black smoke? Thats basically what your forcing this poor fish to do! Live in smoke! Well, not really, more like crap from the CC and from setting it up...but still, you all get the point. And no offense Puffer, but please use periods. Your run-on sentences are driving me crazy. (sorry. not trying to sound like a grammar teacher) Its just hard to tell when you change subjects or who you are talking to.