What are YOUR thoughts...

garnet13aj

Active Member
Reefreak29: garnet your beating a dead horse
I don't get it are you the dead horse? I'm trying to prove a point and have a healthy discussion, if you don't want to hear it, don't keep checking up on the thread. This could be an intelligent discussion but all you bring to it is sacasm and negativity, which isn't very Christian if that's what you claim to be.
reefreak29the earth doesnt move around the sun because science says so , it moves around the sun because it does
Until scientists discovered that the Earth revolved around the sun it was believed the opposite, same with the Earth being flat. Until scientists discovered these things practically the entire human population believed otherwise.
 

zman1

Active Member
I think what he is trying to say is, what is the defacto standard that people stand up for today will change with new found revelations of tomorrow. Blood-letting was once an accepted standard of the science community. Humans have been wrong before....
 

garnet13aj

Active Member
While scientists could be wrong we can either believe a strong consensus by scientists throughout the world, we can do tests ourselves to disprove them, or we can choose to believe that all science is fallible enought to not ever be believed. One and 2 are reasonable actions to take, 3 means that there will never be advancements in technology and healthcare ever again (if everyone takes that stance).
As far as bloodletting goes, was there any suggestion that that actually helped, I believe most of those people died anyway because when it got to that point when they thought bloodletting was needed the person was pretty far gone anyway.
I definitely agree that science can be wrong, but the stronger the consensus is and the more experiments that are done,the less likely they hypothesis is to be wrong.
 

reefreak29

Active Member
Originally Posted by garnet13aj
I don't get it are you the dead horse? I'm trying to prove a point and have a healthy discussion, if you don't want to hear it, don't keep checking up on the thread. This could be an intelligent discussion but all you bring to it is sacasm and negativity, which isn't very Christian if that's what you claim to be.
Until scientists discovered that the Earth revolved around the sun it was believed the opposite, same with the Earth being flat. Until scientists discovered these things practically the entire human population believed otherwise.
thats because scientist said it was flat
 

zman1

Active Member

Originally Posted by garnet13aj
As far as bloodletting goes, was there any suggestion that that actually helped, I believe most of those people died anyway because when it got to that point when they thought bloodletting was needed the person was pretty far gone anyway.
No wrong - used as preventive as well and taught at the universities. However, you can choose to believe or not believe document history from the science community on this particular one.
No one said to discount all scientist, just that popular belief has been wrong before at any given time in history, so keep an open mind and don't always
follow the popular herd over the cliff. Remember, what we consider barbaric today was someone's State-Of-Art in the past.
I am not saying they are right or wrong, only history will play out this body of knowledge for confirmation
 

garnet13aj

Active Member
I agree that scientists have been wrong in the past and will be wrong in the future, but I think people like to site the times that science has been wrong and don't consinder all the times that they have been right.
Most of the reason's people have sited on this thread of why they don't believe global warming exists and/or is human induced is that humans have been wrong before so they don't trust them, no actual facts except other planets are warming. I don't think that is a good enough reason to risk the lives of my future children/grandchildren and many species on this earth that are important to the natural life cycle that are going extinct.
I do think the warming of other planets is something to look into, but it could be that are plaents are warming through a natural cycle whereas ours is warming due a natural cycle but it's acclerated by human activity and that's the difference.
 

garnet13aj

Active Member
Originally Posted by reefreak29
thats because scientist said it was flat
I think it was because until scientists looked into it, it appeared to everyone to be flat not just scientists.
 

reefreak29

Active Member
Originally Posted by garnet13aj
I think it was because until scientists looked into it, it appeared to everyone to be flat not just scientists.
well i guess we can just agree to disagree
 

zman1

Active Member
Originally Posted by garnet13aj
BTW zman1 what are your thoughts on global warming I can't tell by your posts/
I voted that we humans have an impact on the environment too include global warming. Be it pollution and cutting down the CO2/Oxygen converters. That's my believe and it could be wrong....
However, as you can tell, I am not a radical zealot about it....
 

garnet13aj

Active Member
I don't consider myself a radical zealot either, I don't pressure my friends or family to do more to help the environment although I feel strongly about the subject myselft. The reason I assert my beliefs so strongly here is that I specifically made this thread to have this type of discussion so of course I'm going to say how I feel and back it up with facts when possible and hope that other people wil speak openly as well and try to back up what they say as well.
btw, zman1 I'll check out the site you posted and let you know what I think.
 

saltn00b

Active Member
wow this thread has gone in so many directions , i dont even know where to begin. if i touched on every aspect of it i could be here all night, but then again i am staying late to get some OT so maybe i Should:
here are my 200 cents:
1) So far every refutation i have heard thus far, be it people on this board or the websites that supposedly put up 'good arguments against climate change' have been relying on quite few things. The big one that keeps coming back is that everything is cyclical and the earth has cooled and warmed before and its just merely happening again. Well a perfect example of this cycle, taken from the Refuting site TX Reef posted, is this graph showing CO2 concentrations for the last 400,000 years. most of you know Co2 is the single biggest concern for green house gasses and both sides of the fence agree that it's presence historically mirrors the world's temperature. In attempting to debunk this so -called myth, this site puts their virtual foot in their own mouth as the cold hard data depicts here:

yes, you see the nice sinuous wave pattern for 400,000 years of CO2 and temperatures waning and waxing. fast forward to year 2000, at the left most, current side of the scale, at the top of what appears to be the apex of another normal hot cycle, the staggering green line, sky rockets vertically ~100ppmv's. thats about a 135% increase, and the highest recorded concentration on this study by at least 70 ppmv's. eye opening to say the least.
The point is: yes, there has always been a cycle, however we have broken the cycle in the last 100 years of industry. Nobody but desperate politicians and the clergymen that they clamor to still hold on to the absurdity that this is not an accepted fact.
For those who say i dont know, wait it out and see: there are a million sayings in the english language that will preach to you about the ignorance of inaction and procrastination, you chose the one that fits you best.
for those who don't believe what science has to say because they were wrong about the earth being flat: You need to stop taking the word of a man in a robe as the word of god. Yes science has been wrong before, and it will continue to make errors. Consider this: Technology grows at exponential rates. If you drew it out on a graph, it wouldnt be a straight line, not even a very high rate-of-climb, but it would curve upwards to the cusp of infinity. That is a fact. With technologies making leaps and strides it empowers the scientific community with better and better tools to perform the tasks and calculations and tests with minimal error. With each passing year, the rate of error for prediction models and forecasts continue to deminish with impressive odds. This is at the root of it, math. Cold Hard numbers. If anything on this planet or universe is perfect, from atoms to constellations, it is math, the universal language. It has been called God's Language, which makes sense if you are religious, because then only two things are perfect, god and math.... unless god is math ? that is a different thread tho.
i forgot some of the other things i have seen that i wanted to touch on but some interesting things to note:
The internal combustion Engine, the machine that powers the average car, and runs by controlled explosions / ignitions of gasoline, has been obsolete for 60 years. Can you think of any other technology that is still widely used 60 years past its prime? I cant. The only painfully obvious reason IMO, is that Big Oil has been running this country since WWII. again that is probably for another thread.
But did you also know that cell technology has yielded a built and tested a Engine that produces power by harnessing the power released from the breaking down of H20 molecules. This means in lamens terms, in an engine that runs on water, and emitts Oxygen and Hydrogen. yeah.
while that technology might be still be in our future as kinks likely need to be worked out, their is Ethanol. A fuel for engines built very similar to ICE's that is derived from the Soy bean. Soy is (i believe) the second most common cultivated plant on the planet, next to rice. This fuel is worlds cleaner than gasoline for so many reasons. The Country of Brazil, RIGHT NOW has 50% of its gas-station converted to Ethanol, and next year they will have 100% Ethenol 'gas'. The country will be totally Oil independent and will have no reason to deal with any countries in the middle east save for trade like they might with any other country. If the US was totally Oil independent, there would be no troops in Iraq, would there?
Like i said, there are just too many facets to cover everything but if you seriously can sit there and say you don't believe that climate change is happening unnaturally due to human causes, then - i would like to see some facts to prove otherwise.
 

garnet13aj

Active Member
For those who say i dont know, wait it out and see: there are a million sayings in the english language that will preach to you about the ignorance of inaction and procrastination, you chose the one that fits you best
One of my favorites is:
We are now faced with the fact, my friends, that tomorrow is today. We are confronted with the fierce urgency of now. In this unfolding conundrum of life and history, there is such a thing as being too late.
Procrastination is still the thief of time. Life often leaves us standing bare,

[hr]
, and dejected with a lost opportunity. The tide in the affairs of men does not remain at flood-it ebbs. We may cry out desperately for time to pause in her passage, but time is adamant to every plea and rushes on. Over the bleached bones and jumbled residues of numerous civilizations are written the pathetic words "Too late." There is an invisible book of life that faithfully records our vigilance in our neglect. Omar Khayyam is right: "The moving finger writes, and having write moves on."
-Martin Luther King Jr
saltn00b: Thanks for putting in your 200 cents, you're much more articulate than I am.
 

saltn00b

Active Member
No need to thank me, thank Albert.
"If at first, the idea is not absurd, then there is no hope for it"
-Al Einstein
 

reckler

Member
you had asked a question about global warming and I answered it as truthfull as I could without getting kicked off this site. I'm not here to argue with anyone about anything in the world. I am here to learn about saltwater fish and on occation relax in the aquarium with some of my friends and have a good time. If I were really interested in global warming I would find a blog site dedicated to global warming and give up the hobby of saltwater fish and corals. This is a free country and you have every right to express your oppinions, as do I. I would be more interested in talking about how I can help save the reef's in our oceans and stop ocean polution.
Not everyone will believe in what you believe in. I'm no DR. or PHD. in anything. I just tell it like I believe in it. If you think global warming is such a problem, ride a bike, disconnect your power, and don't cook with gass. that will be the start of a change to stop this global warming..
I will not come back to this thread, so say what you will, I would rather devote my time here learning about fish and corals and to try and help other people with the same..
Thank you for understanding, Ron
 

reefreak29

Active Member
Originally Posted by reckler
you had asked a question about global warming and I answered it as truthfull as I could without getting kicked off this site. I'm not here to argue with anyone about anything in the world. I am here to learn about saltwater fish and on occation relax in the aquarium with some of my friends and have a good time. If I were really interested in global warming I would find a blog site dedicated to global warming and give up the hobby of saltwater fish and corals. This is a free country and you have every right to express your oppinions, as do I. I would be more interested in talking about how I can help save the reef's in our oceans and stop ocean polution.
Not everyone will believe in what you believe in. I'm no DR. or PHD. in anything. I just tell it like I believe in it. If you think global warming is such a problem, ride a bike, disconnect your power, and don't cook with gass. that will be the start of a change to stop this global warming..
I will not come back to this thread, so say what you will, I would rather devote my time here learning about fish and corals and to try and help other people with the same..
Thank you for understanding, Ron
 
Top