Quote:
Originally Posted by
GeriDoc http:///t/388324/fast-and-furious-gun-walker#post_3424993
The assertion that "Every state that has made it easier for citizens to carry firearms has had a dramatic reduction in crime" is almost true, but completely misleading. Texas, which eased carry rules in the mid 1990s, did have a 13% reduction in violent crime (vs. 2010). If you consider a 13% reduction as a "dramatic reduction" then fair enough. But New York, which has tightened its carry rules and enforcement has seen a 57% reduction in violent crime in the same time period, would have to be considered spectacular by the same standard. I enjoy going out to the range as much as anyone, but I certainly feel safer in New York, and not because I have guns in the trunk of my car.
The rate of violent crime was far worse in NY than TX to begin with, so I can believe that. But the fact that NYC has 34000 cops who are all over the city 24 hours a day has gone a long way toward easing that crime rate. Our nation cannot afford to have the population equivalent of police to citizens throughout the country-nor should we. The taxes required to support such a police state is unbelievable. And, frankly, NYC is the exception by far. Look at Philly, Boston, Detroit, Chicago, LA, SF, etc, it is quite a different story. Geri, the fact that you would rather be in NY, than San Angelo explains it all.
Here in Cochise County we are larger than 6 states and have a population of 120k. You willing to pay to have a cop on every street corner for me? But all these statistics are a distraction for me. While I would rather have a weapon and depend on myself and have a less intrusive government, that really means little. Our Constitution gives every American the right to bear(carry) arms for national and personal defense and, according to John Adams and Thomas Jefferson in the Federalist Papers, to keep those in government from over-stepping their bounds. Not for over-throwing the government, but to keep a healthy fear of the people in the politicians and bureaucrats. I get that a lot of people are too afraid to take care of themselves and want the police to be their security blanket, but self determination must also have self reliance and you can't have freedom and a police state. Trading freedom for the illusion of security doesn't make one civilized, just cowardly. The right to bear arms isn't just for us "gun nuts". It's your right as well. If you choose not to exercise your right, that doesn't negate the need for or the right itself.