Originally Posted by Darth Tang
You know, I have been thinking about the whole cycling debate.....and if you really think about....unless you cycle with live rock or fish food you are all cruel. I know the arguement that its is torture on the fish...but if you think about it using a dead shrimp is also cruel. Why? Well at one point the shrimp was in the ocean mind it's own business and the next thing it knows it is caught in a net or trap, dragged out of the water and suffocated. Then peeled, packaged and shipped off to the store for our pleasure......
By continuing to buy shrimp you are just telling the corporations that this practice is ok and you are fine with shrimp suffocation.
Atleast with the damsel cycle senario you are allowing the fish a chance to live in an environment free of predators........eventually.
Which is truly more humane?
I don't care about cost....but truly think about it. The argument is actually in a sense dumb......do you think God or evolution (depending on your belief) threw a bunch of dead shrimp in the ocean?
(For the record I cycle with rock and fish food with the exception of my first and second tank. I used mollies for the first and a dead shrimp for the other. Incidentally my first tank is the only one to never give me algae problems. Not sure if there is something to that or not. )
Well, by your reasoning, adding fish food to the tank to cycle is also cruel... as even flakes include some sort of sea life, such as shrimp, squid, and others.
Hmmm... in that case, having LR is cruel as well... At one point in time (whether it be transporting it from the beach to the store, or the store to you), something on it dies... that is the unnecessary death of many colonies of bacteria and microorganisms...
We just shouldn't have fish tanks at all!!!!!