There's no voter fraud

jerthunter

Active Member
Quote:
Originally Posted by Darthtang AW http:///t/391215/theres-no-voter-fraud/20#post_3468451
who exactly does not have a picture id. to gain a legal job one must have one......,.to apply for government assistance you must have one....so who doesnt......criminals and homeless? the homeless cant vote because you need an address to vote....so again...that leaves criminals.....
Well actually the homeless CAN vote sooooooo....
Back to your point, I don't know or really care, but there are people who do. And maybe it should be a law, unfortunately it would be unconstitutional due to the 24th ammendment if it resulted in people having to pay to vote.
 

darthtang aw

Active Member
the homeless can vote if the were already registered...if not.....they cant.....because an address is required on registration...homeless have no legal address.
i get your point...i just dont see it as unconstitutional.....as it is not classified as a tax.
 

jerthunter

Active Member
Quote:
Originally Posted by Darthtang AW http:///t/391215/theres-no-voter-fraud/40#post_3468455
the homeless can vote if the were already registered...if not.....they cant.....because an address is required on registration...homeless have no legal address.
i get your point...i just dont see it as unconstitutional.....as it is not classified as a tax.
Well I'll have to look into the homeless case because I believe they can.. otherwise that would probably violate a few other ammendments (like the 15th)
I think it would be a pretty hard arguement to the courts to explain that costs associated with a voting id aren't a poll tax, but it might be interesting to see the argument
 

reefraff

Active Member
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jerthunter http:///t/391215/theres-no-voter-fraud/40#post_3468457
Well I'll have to look into the homeless case because I believe they can.. otherwise that would probably violate a few other ammendments (like the 15th)
I think it would be a pretty hard arguement to the courts to explain that costs associated with a voting id aren't a poll tax, but it might be interesting to see the argument
Homeless, no residence. What precinct would they register in? Everyone is registered and vote by precinct.
Most if not all the states that are passing voter ID laws are offering free ID's for those with no license.
 

jerthunter

Active Member
Concerning homeless, I haven't had a chance to look it up but I believe there are cases. Fisher v Stout or Ficher v Stout...
Anyway they can designate their street corner or whatever...
Like I said the 15th ammendment would be where I'd go for homeless voting rights and the 24th for no poll tax.
Free IDs would be more likely to work but you still have the issue of access and you have to deal with the issue of loss, damage, counterfeiting.. etc.
 

reefraff

Active Member
Not sure but I do remember the case where the SEIU was trading cigs for votes from homeless people.
 

jerthunter

Active Member
Quote:
Originally Posted by reefraff http:///t/391215/theres-no-voter-fraud/40#post_3468487
Not sure but I do remember the case where the SEIU was trading cigs for votes from homeless people.
That would be illegal IF they were trading them for specific votes. i.e. Vote for Obama and I'll give you this, or even implying that they need to vote for someone.... BUT if they were just getting them to vote, assuming they'd vote the way they wanted, then it would be grey area legal
 

reefraff

Active Member
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jerthunter http:///t/391215/theres-no-voter-fraud/40#post_3468491
That would be illegal IF they were trading them for specific votes. i.e. Vote for Obama and I'll give you this, or even implying that they need to vote for someone.... BUT if they were just getting them to vote, assuming they'd vote the way they wanted, then it would be grey area legal
Not sure if charges were ever filed. It happened in WIsconsin back in 2000
 

bionicarm

Active Member
Quote:
Originally Posted by Darthtang AW http:///t/391215/theres-no-voter-fraud/20#post_3468441
How hard is it to obtain a valid photo idnetification card. People with limited means of transportation manage to go down to the social offices for welfare and food stamp form submissions. Give me a break.
I just gave you an example of voter fraud. You can register a dog to vote for christs sake and receive your voter registration card in the mail. If it wasn't a big deal....why is he now possibly facing 5 years in jail and/or a 10,000 dollar fine. Apparently you don't read news stories to well.
This occurred in your own backyard even. Dallas County
Melvin Porter, although he died in January 2007, cast a vote in the March 4, 2008 Democratic primary in Dallas County. A subsequent investigation by Texas Watchdog turned up the names of 6,000 dead voters on the Dallas County list of registered voters
For some people in rural areas, it's a one or two hour drive to the closest DPS office. You also have to factor in you need some sort of documentation to prove who you are (i.e birth certificate). You'd be amazed at the number of elderly people who no longer drive that don't have an official copy of their birth certificate. So now they have to go to their County Registry, and PAY for a copy of their birth certificate once they can prove they are the person requesting the document. So they have to find transportation to that office, then they have to find a way to whatever DPS office is close to them. The DPS offices in Texas are only open 8 - 6, monday through Friday. What if you work and can't get off during those times? What if you need someone to take you, and they can't get off of work? As it stands, most voting precincts are in local neighborhoods where they are easily accessible for these people to get to.
I have an aunt and uncle that live in Northeast Texas that haven't had a need for an ID for over twenty years. They basically live off the land, either growing their own food, or raising it (they have cattle, goats, pigs, and a good sized chicken coop that gives them all the chicken and eggs they need.) My cousins live in the same area, and bring them any other staples they need. When it comes to voting, they catch a ride down to their local community center where everyone knows who they are. My uncle would probably cuss someone out if they dare asked him for an ID. Now if he wants to vote, he has to get one of his kids to take him 1 1/2 hours to Austin to get this ID. I personally don't see it happening, but he'll follow the law if he has to.
Citizens for Election Integrity Minnesota (CEIMN), in collaboration with MUUSJA, released a report on November 22, 2010, detailing results of a survey sent to all of Minnesota’s County Attorneys. The authors gathered extensive data about County Attorney investigations into ineligible voting and prosecutions of voter fraud based on the 2008 elections.
The report shows that of 2.9 million ballots cast in the 2008 statewide election, only nine ten-thousandths of one percent (0.0009%) of votes cast led to convictions for fraud. Based on the findings of the report, MUUSJA Voting Rights co-chair
Jennifer Jewel Thomas led off the press conference by saying "let me give you the executive summary: voter fraud is not a problem in Minnesota and a photo identification requirement for voters is completely unnecessary." Carol Johnson, report co-author and MUUSJA Voting Rights co-chair, presented attendees an overview of the safeguards in place in Minnesota to protect the integrity of our elections.
http://www.truthaboutfraud.org/pdf/TruthAboutVoterFraud.pdf
Your question about the guy registering his dog to vote brings up a good question - why would anyone purposely commit voter fraud knowing they could face a big fine and prison time? What would they have to gain? In order to change the results of an election, in most cases you'd have to have at least 5% of the total votes cast to be fraudulent in any major election. If this is a national election like the President, you're talking HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS (if not more) of fraudulent votes in order to change the outcome of that election. I imagine you could influence some local elections if you could muster up enough illegal votes, but there's been no reported cases of this occurring that I've ever read.
 

darthtang aw

Active Member

For some people in rural areas, it's a one or two hour drive to the closest DPS office.  You also have to factor in you need some sort of documentation to prove who you are (i.e birth certificate).  You'd be amazed at the number of elderly people who no longer drive that don't have an official copy of their birth certificate.  So now they have to go to their County Registry, and PAY for a copy of their birth certificate once they can prove they are the person requesting the document.  So they have to find transportation to that office, then they have to find a way to whatever DPS office is close to them.  The DPS offices in Texas are only open 8 - 6, monday through Friday.  What if you work and can't get off during those times?  What if you need someone to take you, and they can't get off of work?  As it stands, most voting precincts are in local neighborhoods where they are easily accessible for these people to get to. 
The supreme court already ruled on those instances. Try reading some links once in a while.
 

reefraff

Active Member
A right isn't supposed to be taxed. But I agree with Darth. If I need ID to exercise my right to buy a gun then it is just as justifiable to require it for voting. I suspect better than 90 percent of adults have ID of some sort anyway. The poll tax argument would make sense if they were requiring a special ID just for voting
 

oscardeuce

Active Member
Quote:
Originally Posted by reefraff http:///t/391215/theres-no-voter-fraud/40#post_3468550
A right isn't supposed to be taxed. But I agree with Darth. If I need ID to exercise my right to buy a gun then it is just as justifiable to require it for voting. I suspect better than 90 percent of adults have ID of some sort anyway. The poll tax argument would make sense if they were requiring a special ID just for voting
Why then do we pay taxes on firearms, ammo? NFA tax alone is $200
 

jerthunter

Active Member
Just because something is a right doesn't mean it has to be free.. The 15th ammendment gives the right vote much like the 2nd gives the right to bar arms. 5he difference is that due to voting issues the 24th ammendment was added giving additional specific protections.
 

oscardeuce

Active Member
Quote:
Originally Posted by reefraff http:///t/391215/theres-no-voter-fraud/40#post_3468556
Why indeed. Why are our tax dollars given to illegal aliens in the form of government services? Why are we taxed to provide cell phones for the poor? I could go on and on.
There you go... "Vote for me and I will give you someone elses' money. Kinda easy to be a liberal. You get to play with other peoples' money.
 

reefraff

Active Member
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jerthunter http:///t/391215/theres-no-voter-fraud/40#post_3468557
Just because something is a right doesn't mean it has to be free.. The 15th ammendment gives the right vote much like the 2nd gives the right to bar arms. 5he difference is that due to voting issues the 24th ammendment was added giving additional specific protections.
But by your reasoning the government should have to pick up every voter and drive them to the polling place because gasoline is a poll tax
 

bionicarm

Active Member
Quote:
Originally Posted by Darthtang AW http:///t/391215/theres-no-voter-fraud/40#post_3468540
The supreme court already ruled on those instances. Try reading some links once in a while.
I read quite a bit. And here in Texas, you now need a photo ID to vote. Apparently the Supreme Court didn't overrule this, so you have thousands of disenfranchised voters that have to come up with an ID for something they've been doing for decades without. Needing a photo ID to drive, to buy liquor, purchase a gun, or to cash a check is a privilege. Voting is a right defined in the Constitution. And before you start spouting 2nd Amendment rights, that gives you the right to bear arms. It doesn't say anything as to how you obtain them. Don't recall needing a photo ID to buy a gun in the classifieds (yea, we've been over that one). A buddy of mine just bought an AK-47 from a friend for $300. His friend picked up the AK, several police-style shotguns, and a couple of hand guns from an estate sale, and didn't want the AK. My buddy handed him $300 cash and walked away with a nice firearm. No photo ID required.
 

jerthunter

Active Member

But by your reasoning the government should have to pick up every voter and drive them to the polling place because gasoline is a poll tax
Not necessarily, you don't need to drive to a polling station, there is walking, voting absentee, geting a free ride from someone else.
But if you have to buy an id for the sole purpose of voting, That is basically a poll tax.
 
Top