Corey I used 3/8" acrylic.....I did euro brace the sump and with figuring with the baffles and the built in fuge tying it together as well, really stiffens the build as well. I actually did a week long water test on the sump when it was out on the glue up table, and had no deflection.....again over time you might see a hair, but you also have to remember the sump won't be full of water all the time....You have to keep in mind that max maybe 12" of water in the sump with the exception of power outages, and water changes.....But again I do my water changes usually from the sump, so not very often. I did a bigger sump 60"L x 18"H x 16"W for my 240 with 1/4" and no problems again....A lot really depends on bracing.
Just remember when your doing your euro bracing to not cut the corners square. Leaving them square if it is stressed it will crack the corners. Use a radius curve going into the corners to distribute the load/stress of the bracing....... Your building a new sump?