Thanks for the replies everyone. Mbos, I wouldn't start a new setup just for the idol because I believe that they probably should be in tanks no less than 180 gallons, just for water stability alone. And I'm not setting up another large tank... just don't want one.
Originally Posted by
cristiangarcia
http:///forum/post/2848990
I know that I'm on here alot...I hope nobody would get mad at me but I really think thats sad that you have that sting ray.. He really needs to be in the ocean, I mean look at him, he's so beautiful and to keep him in that "small tank" is a shame. He really shouldnt be there and it makes me sad to see those pics! Hate me if you will, I really dont care but thats the only fish on here that I ever felt really sad for. That fish truly belongs in the ocean ...not a house! Well I'm sure I'll here it soon..
Cristian, I don't hate you. But you are a hypocrit.... that is, if you have an aquarium. I'll take your argument a step further... ALL SALTWATER FISH BELONG IN THE OCEAN. To differentiate between your tang and my stingray is pretty arbitrary. None of these animals are domesticated. We are all keeping fish based on our own self-interests and not to provide a service to the animal. And we are not environmentalists... our hobby does far more harm than good. But how is it any more of an injustice to keep a 12" ray versus a 12" lionfish?
Do you take up for the cause of the ray and not a captive angelfish because you just think the ray is cute? Now, if you are arguiing that keeping saltwaterfish in aquariums is entirely wrong, then you have a much better point, IMO.