What Is This?

brokendeck

Active Member
meowzer;3030053 said:
HMMMM...This is where you lose my expertise

Could be some sort of sponge stuff...BUT I honestly have no clue...Although I think I had something like that...and I THINK I was told some sort of sponge...
Sorry...That's all I know about that
[/QUOTE
Its ok was just making sure it wouldnt kill everything in my tank!
 

pezenfuego

Active Member
Probably a sponge. Now, was it always there? If it has been growing at a fast rate, then it is likely not a sponge. Sponges (like all animals) are heterotrophic, so they can't utilize nutrients and sunlight for food. Instead, they use their collar cells to draw in food through their pores and amoebocytes to distribute the food. They feed on plankton in the water column. Alga and photosynthetic bacterium utilize nutrients and sunlight directly from the water column. Now, the abundance of light and nutrients are FAR more prominent than phytoplankton in aquariums. Therefore, the rate of growth experienced by sponges would be far less than the rate of growth for algae and photosynthetic bacteria.
In short, if it grows and spreads quickly, it is a problem. If it grows and spreads slowly, it isn't going to be a problem. Since it is obviously not a cnidarian, it can't use chemical warfare or nemotocysts to harm organisms in the tank. I can't see a way that it could produce toxic substances either. Even algae isn't harmful, it is just unsightly. This stuff imo isn't ugly...but I certainly wouldn't want it to overtake my tank.
Looks like a sponge, but I guess it could possibly be (oh crap...the word is escaping me). Anyway, the other thing I think it might be isn't harmful either...
Anyway, sorry to rant. Answer my question (growth rate and if it was there when you started) and don't worry about it
 

meowzer

Moderator
Brokendeck;3030093 said:
Originally Posted by meowzer
http:///forum/post/3030053
HMMMM...This is where you lose my expertise

Could be some sort of sponge stuff...BUT I honestly have no clue...Although I think I had something like that...and I THINK I was told some sort of sponge...
Sorry...That's all I know about that
[/QUOTE
Its ok was just making sure it wouldnt kill everything in my tank!
WELLL...it could be that killer sponge that some people get

 

pezenfuego

Active Member
Originally Posted by meowzer
http:///forum/post/3030347
WHAT...You have something better to do....NOW I'm insulted PEZ

I have just been frustrated with people today. I asked my English teacher a question today and instead of an answer, I got some random statement about poetry that had nothing to do with what I was asking...
Deja Vu...
 

meowzer

Moderator
Originally Posted by PEZenfuego
http:///forum/post/3030350
I have just been frustrated with people today. I asked my English teacher a question today and instead of an answer, I got some random statement about poetry that had nothing to do with what I was asking...
Deja Vu...
WELLL...I am very sorry for your bad day....I had a bad day yesterday and I didn't crab at you.....
SO CHEER UP!!!!
 

brokendeck

Active Member
Originally Posted by PEZenfuego
http:///forum/post/3030327
You didn't answer my questions. Did you have that when you got the rock? Has it grown any? How quickly?
If you read the above it will tell you that it was on the rock when I bought it this saturday. No I didnt have it before this rock. Its only on the 2 pieces I bought. It hasent grown any.
 

pezenfuego

Active Member
Originally Posted by Brokendeck
http:///forum/post/3030372
If you read the above it will tell you that it was on the rock when I bought it this saturday. No I didnt have it before this rock. Its only on the 2 pieces I bought. It hasent grown any.
Yes, I realize it was on the rock, I know that these things don't appear out of nowhere. I was wondering if all of it was there at the time...if it hasn't grown, then like I said it isn't using nutrients from the water and sunlight like photosynthetic protists and bacteria would. Therefore it isn't a threat whatsoever. Leave it, it will filterfeed. Sorry to be a female dog.
 

pezenfuego

Active Member
Originally Posted by Brokendeck
http:///forum/post/3030377
Well, I mean noone tells you to use the forums. So dont take it out on others when you had a bad day.
noone...not a word.
I was frustrated that you didn't answer my question when it was not at all to my benefit whether or not you did.
 

brokendeck

Active Member
Originally Posted by meowzer
http:///forum/post/3030387
be nice....

Well its the truth. If someone who has a bad day and acts like this, how am I suppose to act? Just deal with it? If thats the case ill be glad to go find another forum for help.
 

pezenfuego

Active Member
Originally Posted by Brokendeck
http:///forum/post/3030398
Well its the truth. If someone who has a bad day and acts like this, how am I suppose to act? Just deal with it? If thats the case ill be glad to go find another forum for help.
Actually, I had a very good day. I just felt that spending 10 minutes typing that up was a complete waste of time since the basic question I wanted you to answer was ignored.
 
Top